NFL Survivor Contests: Outwit Outlast Outplay Your Opponents

Jack Andrews
Elimination Contests
NFL
September 4, 2022

NFL Survivor Contests

On Friday, we updated our look at NFL handicapping contests for 2022. Today we’re going to update our take on NFL survivor contests. Survivor contests take NFL season-long contests to a whole other level with their simplicity. Pick one game each week. If your teams wins, you move on. If your team loses, you are eliminated. Oh, and you can’t pick the same team twice. What begins as a trivial exercise in Week 1 becomes a grueling gauntlet a few weeks later.

This week we will take the same formula for success that we outlined in NFL pickem contests and apply it to NFL elimination contests such as the popular Circa Survivor contest in Nevada.

 

Elimination Based NFL Handicapping Contests

Most NFL survivor contests do not require you to pick against the spread. You just pick an outright winner each week. One notable exception is the Last Man Standing contest at Stations Casinos in Nevada. For years, they were the popular elimination contest in Las Vegas despite similar contests being run at other sportsbooks such as William Hill.

Again, along came Circa Sports to shake up the scene in 2020. They launched Circa Survivor which was played without a spread. Just pick a winner each week straight up. They offered a $1 million dollar bonus split among anyone who could go perfect over the course of the season. However, they made Thanksgiving its own week. In 2020, large upsets were less frequent and 35 out of 1,390 entrants completed a perfect 18-0 season. That winner-take-all $1.39 million dollar prize (plus $1m bonus) was split 35 ways.

Last year, despite the NFL regular season expanding by one week, Circa upped the ante. Christmas games were also their own week and to achieve the bonus you needed to save Tampa Bay or Kansas CIty until Week 20. They also offered an unprecedented $6 million guarantee, which in the end created a hefty overlay.

In this column last year, I predicted the Survivor would be named around Christmas. To my surprise, five entries ran the entire gauntlet and finished the season 20-0 (including one Unabated Discord member, who got some private coaching tips from Rufus & myself). Three of those five even qualified to split that $1 million bonus for saving KC & Tampa Bay to the end. 4,082 entries in 2021. This meant each entry had an EV of $1,470 for their $1,000 entry fee. I’m not sure why I’m bothering to tell you all this. It was a HUGE story last year and if you’re reading this you probably already knew.

 

Circa’s Twist For 2022

This year, Derek Stevens and his Circa Sports crew are once again guaranteeing $6 million to be paid out. As with last year, you’ll need to go a perfect 20-0 or be the last entry standing to win your share of the prize. There is no 2nd place. There is a bonus again this year, but to qualify you have to go 20-0 and not use the Cincinnati Bengals or the Los Angeles Rams for the entire duration of the contest.

An additional wrinkle in 2022 is that if you enter and lose on the very first game of the year, Rams v. Bills, you are allowed to enter again. This helps eliminate an advantage play some were looking for last year where you could wait for an upset in the kickoff game (last year was Cowboys at Buccaneers) and guarantee a bigger overlay due to eliminated players.

 

Other Survivor-type Contests

In addition to Circa, some regulated online sportsbooks, such as DraftKings, also offer elimination pools with guaranteed top prizes. As is the custom for regulated online sportsbooks in the US these days, they have no fear of leaving an overlay on the table for the advantage players. The DraftKings contest has a $1 million guarantee and only costs $100 to enter in any of the 12 states where it is legal. That means they will need 10,000 entries to avoid an overlay. It’s currently at 4,500 and I’d guess it’ll get to 10,000 – but they won’t mind if it doesn’t.

 

The Plan For Profiting In Survivor Contests

In the handicapping contest article we listed four key concepts to use in approaching NFL Handicapping contests. We are also going to apply them to NFL survivor contests:

  1. Participation
  2. Prize Probability
  3. Process
  4. Path

 

Key Concept: Participation

As with other contests (and honestly, as with anything in a sportsbook), you need to know and understand the rules explicitly. What happens if a game ends in a tie? What happens if a game is postponed but still played? When does my pick need to be in?

As mind-boggling as it may be, there are people who forget to put their entry into these contests for Week 1! In 2020, famous advantage player and Las Vegas Advisor publisher, Anthony Curtis, made that contest-ending mistake. If you don’t submit an entry – you’re out!

Your preparation adds to your EV. You get to overcome the dead money in the pool from entrants that didn’t take the time to study the rules. If you’re in Circa Survivor this year, remember that you only have SIX teams to choose from on the Thanksgiving Day games and EIGHT teams on the Christmas Day  and Day-After-Christmas games. Also pay close attention to that Christmas week where the window to get your play in for games on 12/25 & 12/26 is only NINE hours from 12am to 9am on Christmas Day!

 

Key Concept: Prize Probability

circa nfl survivor contestsEnough with the small talk let’s bring some math in here to quantify how you’re going to find an edge in a contest where almost all the prize pool goes to most likely one entrant. Calculating and projecting an overlay is the first concept. This is done by dividing the prize pool by the number of entrants. Circa is currently getting a lot of attention due to the impending eye-popping overlay in Circa Survivor.

Your odds of winning an elimination contest are much like your odds of hitting a parlay since you’re going to need to rollover a streak of picking a winner longer than anybody else in the contest. The advantage is you don’t have to pick against a spread. Some weeks of the NFL season there are teams that are -400 favorites (80% implied probability) based on the moneyline. Other weeks maybe a -120 (54.5%) is all you have left to use.

Even if we assumed you could find a 63% chance to win every week, the odds of you running off 20 straight winners is 0.63^20 = .000097, or roughly 1 in ten thousand. Fortunately for you, you’re not competing against the house in a challenge to rip off 20 winners in a row. You’re competing against other entries facing similar odds.

 

Estimating How Long an NFL Survivor Contest Will Last

Last year I gave a formula for trying to estimate how long an NFL survivor contest would probably last. Overwhelmingly, NFL elimination contests follow a predictable pattern. People play the heavy favorites. It gives them the biggest odds of surviving. In our Process section we’re going to explore why that’s not always the best strategy. However, for now let’s correctly assume almost everyone in the contest will pick winners at a 64% success rate.

That means that roughly 64% will survive each week. However, how long would we need to survive to win a contest like that? We can use the LOG function in Excel to give us an estimate. All we need to know is how many entries are in the contest and what their projected success rate is:

=LOG(1/entries,success_rate)

If we estimate that Circa Millions will reach exactly it’s overlay point, that would be 6000 entries. A 64% success rate would be:

=LOG(1/6000,.64)

= 19.49

That is projecting an elimination contest with 6000 entrants and a 64% pick success rate will on average resolve around week 19.49 (we can round up to 20 since there are no partial weeks). However, there’s also clumping involved since a large proportion of the entries will likely be on the same play each week. This 20 week estimate is probably +/- 3 weeks due to clumping of outcome. You can play around with those numbers a bit to create your own projections. You may also want to tweak the predicted success rate per your inclination.

Either way, the answer does provide us with a key piece of information: This is a marathon, not a sprint. Circa Survivor is likely to last nearly to the end of the season. That brings us to our next key concept, Process.

 

Key Concept: Process

The biggest misnomer in these NFL elimination contests is that the object is just survive the longest. After all, it’s called Circa Survivor. Ironically, it is the logo for the long-running reality show Survivor which gives us a clue about how these should really be approached.

Survivor Contests

Outwit – Outplay – Outlast

In these contests, you are in first place until you finish in last place. There is no second-place or consolation prize. In fact, I would contend the worst outcome is to make a deep run in this contest and come up short. You wasted a lot of time.

Instead, your goal shouldn’t just be to survive, but to outwit and outplay your opponents. Identify points where you can hopefully eliminate a large portion of your opposition while you survive to the next week. It is obvious that most of the entries will focus on the biggest moneyline favorite in the week. This is especially true early in the season.

This is the time you can look for a mediocre team playing a bad opponent. Maybe the 3rd or 4th best value based on moneyline. You save some heavy hitters for later in the season and you position yourself for a modest contrarian swing. Many of your opponents aren’t thinking about the pick you are making, but you are certainly thinking about them.

 

Overcoming Your Fears

Many players will quickly reach for the relative safety of taking their last best option as their available remaining teams dwindle. They are painting themselves into a corner with this approach. Remind yourself that there is no second place and be willing to take a risk before you are left with just the bad options.

You don’t have to take the opposite of what everyone will be playing. For instance, taking the Falcons in Week 2 at the Rams is a bridge too far. However, instead of taking the Rams there, look for a game that very few will be playing. Many weeks, this might be the Thursday Night game.

Perhaps people think Thursday games are trap spots for some teams. Perhaps they don’t want to ruin their entire weekend by flunking out of the elimination contest days before. For whatever reason, people tend to avoid picking Thursday games. Use that to your advantage.

In the previous article, we explored having a two-speed approach. Staying with the pace of traffic and trying to pass the traffic. Staying with the pace of traffic isn’t an option in elimination contests. You want to always be trying to pass traffic. You don’t have to take a home run swing every week, but you should at least be looking for the road less traveled. That brings us to the final key concept, your path.

 

Key Concept: Path

Just like NFL handicapping contests, you need to establish an endgame strategy with NFL elimination contests. The difference is endgame starts almost at the beginning of the contest. You need to plot out your path right from the jump. You can change your path as the season goes on but you’ll need to factor in how those variations alter your path.

Other useful tools can be found with our friends at TeamRankings. They have a tool I really wish we had at Unabated called PoolGenius. It is a very extensive set of tools and strategy guides that will definitely help you compete in any NFL survivor contest. Your opponents may be relying on sites like SurvivorGrid.com but outwitting them may include using different tools than them.

In a contest such as Circa Survivor your path must account for the Thanksgiving and Christmas games, which limits your pool of teams to only 6 teams on Thanksgiving and 8 on Christmas and the day after. Some players will be tempted to shoot the moon and aim for the extra $1 million dollar bonus if you go 20-0 and avoid playing the Rams or the Bengals. In my opinion, that bonus hunting just complicates your path. Additionally, that million dollar bonus barely move the needle in value. You can be sure some of your opponents will value it though. The three players who split it last year sure appreciate the bonus.

My advice is to create a path now and revisit it frequently. Don’t wait until early November when you find yourself still surviving but with dwindling options. You’ll have visions of a $6 million dollar prize in your head by this time, but no realistic path to get there.

 

Key Takeaways

  • NFL survivor contests begin seeming simple but turn into a very complex equation
  • Following some key concepts can gain the edge over the majority of your opposition
  • Know the rules since any missed entry is a contest-ending mistake
  • Devise a process for attacking the contest
  • There is no second place. You are in first place until you are in last place
  • Don’t be afraid to take risks
  • Utilize tools to help you plot your path
  • Constantly revisit your path as the season progresses